Leprosy Mailing List, September 11th, 2008
Ref.: 20 weeks of Prednisolone are better than 12 weeks in the treatment of reversal reaction (RR)
From: Kar H. K., New Delhi, India
Dear Dr Salvatore,
Thanks. I refer to Dr. Kawuma’s message (LML, Sept. 8th, 2008) on the treatment of reversal reaction (RR or Type 1 reaction). I agree with him. A short course of prednisolone less than 12 weeks is not sufficient to control RR.
Irrespective of the spectrum of the disease, 5 to 6 months (or even more) course of prednisolone is required to control RR along with MDT. When the inflamed lesion of RR is on the face, it may need more than 6 months of prednisolone therapy. You may need to continue tapering dose of steroid few more weeks after the patient has been released from treatment (RFT) to prevent late RR or to treat late RR.
This is our experience.
Best regards.
Dr (Prof.) H K KarMD, MNAMSConsultant & HODDepartment of Dermatology, STD & LeprosyPGIMER, Dr Ram Manohar Lohia HospitalBaba Kharag Singh MargNew Delhi-110001
India
Friday, September 12, 2008
20 weeks of Prednisolone are better than 12 weeks in the treatment of type 1 (reversal) reaction
Leprosy Mailing List, September 8th, 2008
Ref.: 20 weeks of Prednisolone are better than 12 weeks in the treatment of type 1 (reversal) reaction
From: Kawuma H. J., Kampala, Uganda
Dear Salvatore,
I refer to the request by Dr. Ranawaka on the treatment of Type 1 (reversal) reaction (Leprosy Mailing List, August 25th, 2008). I wish to share the experience from Uganda.
Polar types of leprosy, both tuberculoid (TT) and lepromatous (LLp), are rare in our region. We have more cases of sub-polar lepromatous leprosy (LLs), lacking classical features of LLp.
The LLs cases were known to develop protracted and recurrent Type 1 reactions but which when well managed gave a very good result in the end for the patient.
We learnt to use more prolonged treatment with Prednisolone and this has been confirmed by good clinical trials. 20 weeks Prednisolone courses are better than 12 weeks courses. Of course we need to keep in mind other factors (already discussed in this forum) that can precipitate recurrent reactions or poor response to treatment.
H Joseph Kawuma
GLRA, Kampala, Uganda
Ref.: 20 weeks of Prednisolone are better than 12 weeks in the treatment of type 1 (reversal) reaction
From: Kawuma H. J., Kampala, Uganda
Dear Salvatore,
I refer to the request by Dr. Ranawaka on the treatment of Type 1 (reversal) reaction (Leprosy Mailing List, August 25th, 2008). I wish to share the experience from Uganda.
Polar types of leprosy, both tuberculoid (TT) and lepromatous (LLp), are rare in our region. We have more cases of sub-polar lepromatous leprosy (LLs), lacking classical features of LLp.
The LLs cases were known to develop protracted and recurrent Type 1 reactions but which when well managed gave a very good result in the end for the patient.
We learnt to use more prolonged treatment with Prednisolone and this has been confirmed by good clinical trials. 20 weeks Prednisolone courses are better than 12 weeks courses. Of course we need to keep in mind other factors (already discussed in this forum) that can precipitate recurrent reactions or poor response to treatment.
H Joseph Kawuma
GLRA, Kampala, Uganda
Management of nerve abscess in leprosy
Leprosy Mailing List, September 8th, 2008
Ref.: Management of nerve abscess in leprosy
From: Salafia A., Mumbai, India
Dear Salvatore,
This has reference to the on-going discussion about nerves and nerve abscess; let me add one more “last” word.
My colleague and I operate in a referral hospital in Mumbai; 95% of the patients referred to us have been treated elsewhere before coming to us and they are referred because the treatment given has not worked.
After few years of trial and error (because nobody in India used to teach about nerve surgery, as the Indian School (unlike the French School) was against surgery of nerves, in 1990 we formulated our protocol which is still valid. Let me add the we have been seen about 650 neuritis cases a year, out of which only about 100-150 have been operated; in the last year and this year too the number of referred cases has come down significantly to about 250-300 a year.
The protocol for all types of neuritis;
a)We operate, as soon as possible, in cases of "visible swelling" (I repeat, already treated for months on elsewhere without benefit), discharging sinus, increasing neural loss, intractable pain and/or paresthesia.
b)All other cases are first given a course of steroids (most clinicians use 'homeopathic dosages of steroids). In our book we suggest 1mg. of Prednisolone (or its equivalent) per kilo body wt. Our routine is: I.M. injection of Dexamethasone in tapering dosages: start with 8-12 mgs (as per body wt.) per day for 3 day, followed by 6-10 mgs. for another 3 days, and then 4-8 mgs for another 3 days. At this point the patient is assessed: 1.)If all symptoms have disappeared or at least reduced significantly, we prescribe oral steroids - starting from 20-30 mgs. of Prednisolone and taper it over a period of 3-6 months or more (assessment once a month or so).
2.)If the symptoms have not subsided or have increased, then we explore surgically without further ado.
About the statement made by Dr. Warren (LML Sept. 2nd, 2008), that any stroke of knife may increase neural damage, we had the same doubt when we started; but once our protocol was set, this problem was solved.
How you may ask? I trained in microsurgery in 1983 under Prof. G. Brunelli (a world authority on the field) and Dr. Chauhan trained too in 1990 under the same teacher, here in India. In 1990 the hospital received an operation microscope (Zeiss), and every since, we have been using (in almost all cases) operation microscope and microsurgical techniques; in this way the damage to the nerves is nil or almost.
Naked-eye surgery (as it is was done in the past and is even done today by some) is not without risks as mentioned in our book, besides we are against all those dubious procedures like stripping the epineurium, ante position of the ulnar etc.. for reasons clearly stated in our book*.
While dealing with nerve abscess, we have been guilty a few times (if guilty is the right word) of being too cautious; let me explain. We have three cases who came to us with large abscesses of the ulnar and total neural loss; we carried out a surgical toilet, the nerve looked totally necrotic yet we refrained ourselves from removing the 'empty shell' which was the epineurium, in the hope that some nerve fibres might be still viable.
Well, one patient, in whom we did a successful claw-hand repair, come exactly after 10 years with a small abscess in the 'empty shell'; and this point the patient insisted that we explore the nerve and remove whatever there was to remove (we explained to him what had happened). We had no other choice but excise the 'empty shell'. The same has happened in another two cases, both coming to us after 8-10 years from the first surgery. Experience and the operation microscope have taught us when to stop and where... To our students (every year we have a training programme for young surgeons) we teach and show (in the O.T.) what to do and what not to do.
I believe this is enough. Thanks for your patience.
Antonio Salafia
Head of dept. or reconstructive surgery
Vimala hospital
Mumbai
India
*Treatment of Neuritis in Leprosy. Medical and Surgical”. A. Salafia, G. Chauhan, 1997.
Ref.: Management of nerve abscess in leprosy
From: Salafia A., Mumbai, India
Dear Salvatore,
This has reference to the on-going discussion about nerves and nerve abscess; let me add one more “last” word.
My colleague and I operate in a referral hospital in Mumbai; 95% of the patients referred to us have been treated elsewhere before coming to us and they are referred because the treatment given has not worked.
After few years of trial and error (because nobody in India used to teach about nerve surgery, as the Indian School (unlike the French School) was against surgery of nerves, in 1990 we formulated our protocol which is still valid. Let me add the we have been seen about 650 neuritis cases a year, out of which only about 100-150 have been operated; in the last year and this year too the number of referred cases has come down significantly to about 250-300 a year.
The protocol for all types of neuritis;
a)We operate, as soon as possible, in cases of "visible swelling" (I repeat, already treated for months on elsewhere without benefit), discharging sinus, increasing neural loss, intractable pain and/or paresthesia.
b)All other cases are first given a course of steroids (most clinicians use 'homeopathic dosages of steroids). In our book we suggest 1mg. of Prednisolone (or its equivalent) per kilo body wt. Our routine is: I.M. injection of Dexamethasone in tapering dosages: start with 8-12 mgs (as per body wt.) per day for 3 day, followed by 6-10 mgs. for another 3 days, and then 4-8 mgs for another 3 days. At this point the patient is assessed: 1.)If all symptoms have disappeared or at least reduced significantly, we prescribe oral steroids - starting from 20-30 mgs. of Prednisolone and taper it over a period of 3-6 months or more (assessment once a month or so).
2.)If the symptoms have not subsided or have increased, then we explore surgically without further ado.
About the statement made by Dr. Warren (LML Sept. 2nd, 2008), that any stroke of knife may increase neural damage, we had the same doubt when we started; but once our protocol was set, this problem was solved.
How you may ask? I trained in microsurgery in 1983 under Prof. G. Brunelli (a world authority on the field) and Dr. Chauhan trained too in 1990 under the same teacher, here in India. In 1990 the hospital received an operation microscope (Zeiss), and every since, we have been using (in almost all cases) operation microscope and microsurgical techniques; in this way the damage to the nerves is nil or almost.
Naked-eye surgery (as it is was done in the past and is even done today by some) is not without risks as mentioned in our book, besides we are against all those dubious procedures like stripping the epineurium, ante position of the ulnar etc.. for reasons clearly stated in our book*.
While dealing with nerve abscess, we have been guilty a few times (if guilty is the right word) of being too cautious; let me explain. We have three cases who came to us with large abscesses of the ulnar and total neural loss; we carried out a surgical toilet, the nerve looked totally necrotic yet we refrained ourselves from removing the 'empty shell' which was the epineurium, in the hope that some nerve fibres might be still viable.
Well, one patient, in whom we did a successful claw-hand repair, come exactly after 10 years with a small abscess in the 'empty shell'; and this point the patient insisted that we explore the nerve and remove whatever there was to remove (we explained to him what had happened). We had no other choice but excise the 'empty shell'. The same has happened in another two cases, both coming to us after 8-10 years from the first surgery. Experience and the operation microscope have taught us when to stop and where... To our students (every year we have a training programme for young surgeons) we teach and show (in the O.T.) what to do and what not to do.
I believe this is enough. Thanks for your patience.
Antonio Salafia
Head of dept. or reconstructive surgery
Vimala hospital
Mumbai
India
*Treatment of Neuritis in Leprosy. Medical and Surgical”. A. Salafia, G. Chauhan, 1997.
“eMedicine”
Leprosy Mailing List, September 8th, 2008
Ref.: “eMedicine”
From: Frankel R. I., Hawaii, USA
Dear Dr. Noto,
With all due respect, I must take issue with Dr. Compostella's statement "eMedicine is the leading provider of clinical medical information for medical professionals and consumers." (LML Sept. 6th, 2008). It is but one of many sources of clinical medical information, and I certainly do not consider it the leading provider.
I am sure many readers of your list will disagree with statements in this article, such as "The fluid is placed on a glass slide and stained by using the Ziehl-Neelsen acid-fast method or the Fite method to look for organisms." One should certainly avoid the Ziehl-Neelsen stain because of the risk of a false negative result. One can take issue with other statements, but I am writing less to criticize this paper than to caution readers regarding Dr. Compostella's statement.
The lead author of this eMedicine paper is a resident. I have great respect for residents and spent most of my career actively teaching them. I served as Program Director and Deputy Program of the University of Hawai'i Internal Medicine Residency Program. Yet resident are learning and gaining experience and generally have very limited clinical experience and a limited perspective. I was very surprised in the early days of eMedicine when one of my residents told me that she had written a chapter for eMedicine. Residents can certainly do extensive reviews of the literature, yet that does not generally suffice for broad expertise that includes knowledge of more obscure literature, knowledge of data that has been presented but not published, and clinical and research experience.
Thank you.
Richard I. Frankel, M.D., M.P.H., F.A.C.P.Emeritus Professor of MedicineUniversity of Hawai'i
Ref.: “eMedicine”
From: Frankel R. I., Hawaii, USA
Dear Dr. Noto,
With all due respect, I must take issue with Dr. Compostella's statement "eMedicine is the leading provider of clinical medical information for medical professionals and consumers." (LML Sept. 6th, 2008). It is but one of many sources of clinical medical information, and I certainly do not consider it the leading provider.
I am sure many readers of your list will disagree with statements in this article, such as "The fluid is placed on a glass slide and stained by using the Ziehl-Neelsen acid-fast method or the Fite method to look for organisms." One should certainly avoid the Ziehl-Neelsen stain because of the risk of a false negative result. One can take issue with other statements, but I am writing less to criticize this paper than to caution readers regarding Dr. Compostella's statement.
The lead author of this eMedicine paper is a resident. I have great respect for residents and spent most of my career actively teaching them. I served as Program Director and Deputy Program of the University of Hawai'i Internal Medicine Residency Program. Yet resident are learning and gaining experience and generally have very limited clinical experience and a limited perspective. I was very surprised in the early days of eMedicine when one of my residents told me that she had written a chapter for eMedicine. Residents can certainly do extensive reviews of the literature, yet that does not generally suffice for broad expertise that includes knowledge of more obscure literature, knowledge of data that has been presented but not published, and clinical and research experience.
Thank you.
Richard I. Frankel, M.D., M.P.H., F.A.C.P.Emeritus Professor of MedicineUniversity of Hawai'i
Paper on leprosy from “eMedicine”
Leprosy Mailing List, September 6th, 2008
Ref.: Paper on leprosy from “eMedicine”
From: Compostella L., Cortina d'Ampezzo, Belluno, Italy
Dear Salvatore,
I thought you might be interested in this article from eMedicine. You may either click on the following link or copy and paste it into your browser:-http://www.emedicine.com/derm/TOPIC223.HTM
eMedicine is the leading provider of clinical medical information for medical professionals and consumers. To explore eMedicine today, visit http://www.emedicine.com
Best regards,
Leonida
Ref.: Paper on leprosy from “eMedicine”
From: Compostella L., Cortina d'Ampezzo, Belluno, Italy
Dear Salvatore,
I thought you might be interested in this article from eMedicine. You may either click on the following link or copy and paste it into your browser:-http://www.emedicine.com/derm/TOPIC223.HTM
eMedicine is the leading provider of clinical medical information for medical professionals and consumers. To explore eMedicine today, visit http://www.emedicine.com
Best regards,
Leonida
Report of the 9th meeting of the WHO Technical Advisory Group
Leprosy Mailing List, September 6th, 2008
Ref.: Report of the 9th meeting of the WHO Technical Advisory Group
From: Pannikar V., New Delhi, India
Dear Dr Noto,
Please find attached the report of the 9th meeting of the WHO Technical Advisory Group for your kind perusal.
It may also be interest to leprosy discussion list (LML).
Regards,
V. Pannikar
Ref.: Report of the 9th meeting of the WHO Technical Advisory Group
From: Pannikar V., New Delhi, India
Dear Dr Noto,
Please find attached the report of the 9th meeting of the WHO Technical Advisory Group for your kind perusal.
It may also be interest to leprosy discussion list (LML).
Regards,
V. Pannikar
11th Brazilian Congress of Leprology
Leprosy Mailing List, September 5th, 2008
Ref.: 11th Brazilian Congress of Leprology
From: Andrade E., Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Dear Dr Salvatore,
The Brazilian Leprology Society is organizing its 11th National Congress which will take place in the city of Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil, from November 24th till 26th 2008. It is one of the most scientific happening in the field of hanseniasis in Brazil!
One can get information at www.sbhansenologia.org.br and sbhatilsl.br
Contact by phone: 00-55-14-3103-5984 or fax: 00-55-14-3103-5916.
Please post it at the LML!
Best regards,
Eduardo Andrade
NLR Brasil
Ref.: 11th Brazilian Congress of Leprology
From: Andrade E., Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Dear Dr Salvatore,
The Brazilian Leprology Society is organizing its 11th National Congress which will take place in the city of Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil, from November 24th till 26th 2008. It is one of the most scientific happening in the field of hanseniasis in Brazil!
One can get information at www.sbhansenologia.org.br and sbhatilsl.br
Contact by phone: 00-55-14-3103-5984 or fax: 00-55-14-3103-5916.
Please post it at the LML!
Best regards,
Eduardo Andrade
NLR Brasil
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)